ST. AUGUSTINE, Fla. - s4story -- 32259 and 32092 Waterfront Pool Home Market Holds Steady Through August 2026, New MLS Analysis Shows

What does the 2026 waterfront pool home market in 32259 and 32092 mean for homeowners whose property did not sell the first time?

ST. JOHNS COUNTY, Fla., Sept. 22, 2026 — The January-through-August 2026 comparison shows a remarkably steady market for $750,000–$1,000,000 single-family waterfront homes with private pools in ZIP codes 32259 and 32092. For homeowners whose property did not sell the first time, the evidence supports examining the individual home's pricing, presentation, positioning and competition rather than assuming buyers have disappeared.

An analysis of a Sept. 22, 2026 MLS export found 24 qualifying sales from January through August 2026, compared with 25 during the same period in 2025. Median sale price was $841,000 versus $839,000, while median market time was 49 days versus 48.

August alone looked substantially stronger. Six qualifying homes sold at a median $887,150 in August 2026, compared with three at an $800,000 median in August 2025. However, those small samples should not be interpreted as evidence of a broad market trend. The larger eight-month comparison provides stronger context.

More on S For Story

• Nathaniel Amaya McDaniel Releases New Children's Book - Amaya's Welcome to Kindergarten
• New Christian Devotional Invites Believers to a Place of Spiritual Surrender and Deepened Faith
• New Canadian Book Asks: Does This Record Need to Exist?
• Kaplan Morrell and Attorney Jacqui Condon Selected to Represent Professional Women's Soccer Players in Workers' Compensation Matters
• ClearSight Therapeutics Receives NIH SBIR Phase I Award for Conjunctivitis and EKC Research

Qualifying sellers received an average 96.9% of final list price through August 2026, compared with 97.6% during the same period in 2025. As of Sept. 22, eight qualifying properties were active and one was pending across 32259 and 32092.

"The first thing I would want to understand is why buyers selected competing properties," said Michelle Ortelli of The Ortelli Team at Coldwell Banker Vanguard Realty. "A failed first listing should be evaluated against what buyers actually purchased, not simply relisted with the same strategy and a new sign in the yard."

Ortelli's statement is professional observation. The MLS data does not establish why an individual property failed to sell.

Seller Decision FAQs

Should I wait for prices to rise before relisting?
The year-to-date median was $841,000 in 2026 versus $839,000 in 2025. The evidence does not show a large year-over-year price movement that, by itself, makes waiting an obvious solution.

Is now a good time to relist in 32259 or 32092?
Buyers are still purchasing qualifying homes, with 24 sales through August versus 25 a year earlier. The individual property's price, condition, positioning and current competition should also be evaluated.

More on S For Story

• Lunai Bioworks (N A S D A Q: LNAI) Takes Parkinson's Discovery to the Next Level With Exclusive Tanaist Agreement
• Revenue Optics Names Prat Patibandla Director of Growth Marketing
• Former Chef & Travel Writer Kurt Jacobson Guides Readers Through 32 Historic Mid-Atlantic Inns, Hot
• Travel Writer Debbie Stone Captures the Soul of Morocco in New Memoir from Luxe Beat Media
• Independent Autopsies Are Changing Civil Cases: Kansas City Forensic Explains Why Families Are Seeking Second Opinions

What should I review before relisting?
Pricing strategy, property condition, presentation, showing experience, price adjustments and the competing homes buyers actually selected can all warrant review.

About Michelle Ortelli

Michelle Ortelli is with The Ortelli Team at Coldwell Banker Vanguard Realty and has been licensed since 2006.

Source: MLS export supplied Sept. 22, 2026. Scope: $750,000–$1,000,000 single-family homes in 32259 and 32092 with private pool and waterfront fields marked Yes.

Michelle Ortelli |
Trusted Real Estate Advisor in Northeast Florida | Specializing in
Helping Homeowners in St. Augustine | St. Johns County | Northeast Florida Sell with Confidence | Global Luxury | Residential | Relocation | Second Homes | Expired Listings

904-570-8130 | mortelli@cbvfl.com | www.ortelliteam.com/contactme